Stunned believers are flocking to the church to witness the unusual sight that has left even sceptics scratching their heads

One Youtube commentator provided the likely explanation:

New cameras use CCD chips to capture an image. When you zoom in too much it's no longer using the optical sensor but instead the CCD (digital) zoom. Basically by mobbing your camera slightly (i.e holding it) it's causing the pixels of that chip to capture different colors around her lips making it look like their moving. Try filming it again with a higher quality camera and no zoom and I doubt you'll see any movement.

At which point, the person who filmed the video and everyone else who believed this was a miracle said, "Why, of course. That's so obvious. Why didn't I think of that? That'll teach me to be so gullible."

In my dreams, anyway.

Considering the above I doubt if this is related but..

If you've ever been to the Rothko Room at the Tate Modern, there are a few paintings that have an interesting effect that I have witnessed where colors seem to "flow" from lighter to darker areas of his canvases. I attribute this to light levels in the room, under and over painting of colors and how the eye adjusts to the colour it is observing.

It is a pretty wild experience.

felltoearth wrote:Considering the above I doubt if this is related but..

If you've ever been to the Rothko Room at the Tate Modern, there are a few paintings that have an interesting effect that I have witnessed where colors seem to "flow" from lighter to darker areas of his canvases. I attribute this to light levels in the room, under and over painting of colors and how the eye adjusts to the colour it is observing.

It is a pretty wild experience.

I think I've told this story before, but my family went to the Abstract Expressionism New York show at the AGO a few years ago. Normally, my kids (who were 14 and 16 at the time) would go thru an art show more quickly than my wife and I and then wait for us in the gift shop that inevitably forms the final "room" of any big exhibit. This time, however, they doubled back thru the exhibit and when we were done we found them sitting and staring transfixed at one of the Rothkos. We asked if they were ready to leave, and the older replied "Almost."

Back to the topic at hand: If you really thought a picture on your wall was moving its lips, what would you do? You'd pull up a chair or ladder and look at it from as close a distance as you could, right? You wouldn't just take a crappy cell-phone video from a distance and consider the matter settled, like this bozo does. That shows to me he realizes this is just an illusion, and doesn't want to break it.

Chuck E. Cheese's lips don't even move, so this must be a miracle.

It's pretty poor that you can see her lips move while she's speaking for that dummy.

Alan B wrote:Yeah. If you look closely (full screen) at at any of the edges you can see pixilating all over as the image shakes.

Jesus. Some people are so fucking gullible.

In particular, look at the lighter spot on her right shoulder.

Oh ye of little faith. Of course it's a miracle! It's God in his infinite power and wisdom and shit sort of kind of maybe making the lips of a fucking painting move. That's some goddamn He-Man grade power there! Now some might say that he could do something a bit more, well, fucking useful, like reverse global warming or growing a few amputated limbs back, but mysterious ways, dude, mysterious ways. Besides, He couldn't test your faith by being too bleeding obvious, could he?

It's the work of Satan. Hail Satan!

The ironic thing is this guy thinks he's providing evidence for Christianity, when in fact he's doing just the opposite. If a Christian claims that the resurrection must have happened because of the "eyewitness testimony" that proves it, here we have the video evidence to the contrary: People will believe anything if they want to badly enough.

They would believe anything. Remember the moving statues in Ireland. That made a nice bit of money for the locals.

The only religious education any child should ever get is to watch Life of Brian once every school term until they leave school. It will equip them to recognise religious fuckwittery a mile off and laugh at it.

If she is moving her mouth, she doesn't appear to approve.