Thommo wrote:DavidMcC wrote:Thommo, I thought it was obvious that I had actually answered your question about evidence for what you term "extra-dimensional black holes", by saying that all black holes that happen to be close enough in the hyperspace continuum show up in this universe, (just like most black holes in the galaxy, formed from collapsing stars). They would probably be mainly the supermassive black holes thought to be at the centre of most galaxies, and which astronomers and cosmologists alike admit that they cannot explain. My answer is that they were formed in a sister universe that overlaps us in hyperspace.
If you think they have explained them, please supply a link.
Why would you think it obvious you answered?
This was the question:
"If there is evidence of extradimensional black holes existing outside our known cosmos, what is it exactly?"So unless you think that paragraph is evidence, it's obvious you haven't answered it. If you do think that paragraph is evidence, then we've got a pretty fundamental problem on our hands.
If you had read my cosmology articles in the LQG thread, you would know that it depends on piecing together a whole range of otherwise inexplicable astronomical/cosmological observations.
I note that many of these questions could have been asked without even reading my cosmology articles!
EDIT: Having said that, the fact that astronomers cannot understand how the supermassive black holes at the centres of most galaxies could have formed in the time available is perhaps the strongest strand of the evidence for them being in other universes (thatn happen to be nearby, but shifted slightly from us in hyperspace.