duvduv wrote:Excuse me. These were noted other "prophets" with their own Qurans at the time. Anyway, this thread is turning out to be exceedingly unproductive and just plain boring........

you seem very biased against islam/muslims,your threads,post is full of incorrect information.so,where the other QURANS that you are talking about.
Musalayma famously known as the liar ,according to the Wikipedia,was a skilled magician,false prophet and claimed some form of Godness but his claim didnt stop him being killed in a battle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musaylimah

Dark energy wrote:Musalayma famously known as the liar ,according to the Wikipedia,was a skilled magician,false prophet and claimed some form of Godness but his claim didnt stop him being killed in a battle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musaylimah

What's he got to do with the topic? Other, perhaps, just to demonstrate that people made up stories in those days just as they do now. Were these books the original "fake news"?

i was addressing a specific claim made the thread starter.

Dark energy wrote:i was addressing a specific claim made the thread starter.

Sorry, am I missing something? I searched the thread and you were the first to mention Musalayma, who appears to have been a sort of renegade Muslims. The opening post only mentions Mandaeans, who were Gnostics - a different kettle of fish - and after the first page they only appear in a late dismissive comment by The Metatron.
Can you help me here please?

Oeditor wrote:

Dark energy wrote:i was addressing a specific claim made the thread starter.

Sorry, am I missing something? I searched the thread and you were the first to mention Musalayma, who appears to have been a sort of renegade Muslims. The opening post only mentions Mandaeans, who were Gnostics - a different kettle of fish - and after the first page they only appear in a late dismissive comment by The Metatron.
Can you help me here please?

Excuse me. These were noted other "prophets" with their own Qurans at the time. Anyway, this thread is turning out to be exceedingly unproductive and just plain boring........

Musalayma was a false magician prophet who appeared after the demise of Prophet Muhammed in the arabian peninsula and was killed in a battle.i was just following up with his claim.