Has this phrase changed its meaning?
Moderators: Calilasseia, ADParker
CookieJon wrote:Supported by the fact that the mule cannot move away from the stick, and that using a carrot and a stick simultaneously is redundant, some[who?] claim that this usage of phrase is erroneous, and that it in fact comes from the figure of a carrot on a stick. In this case, the driver would tie a carrot on a string to a long stick and dangle it in front of the donkey, just out of its reach. As the donkey moved forward to get the carrot, it pulled the cart and the driver so that the carrot would always remain out of reach.
and “Carrot on a stick” vs. “the carrot or the stick.” reckons the earliest citation is too ambiguous to tell which is "correct".
Vindicated!!
Crocodile Gandhi wrote:Clearly wikipedia isn't going to solve this. I propose Cookiejon and Matt_B have a duel. The winner gets a carrot. The loser is hit with a stick.
Fallible wrote:Crocodile Gandhi wrote:Clearly wikipedia isn't going to solve this. I propose Cookiejon and Matt_B have a duel. The winner gets a carrot. The loser is hit with a stick.
I was going to propose that the chief weapon of one combatant should be general encouragement and a system of rewards, while the other should employ shouted admonishment and violent physical contact.
Crocodile Gandhi wrote:I wouldn't be adverse to such an occurence.
Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 1 guest