Formerly Anthony Kennedy: US supreme court justice to retire. Goodbye Roe v Wade, Obergefell
Moderators: kiore, Blip, The_Metatron
! |
GENERAL MODNOTE Moved by Mod service activated ![]() |
The Supreme Court on Thursday agreed to hear a case that could dramatically change how federal elections are conducted. At issue is a legal theory that would give state legislatures unfettered authority to set the rules for federal elections, free of supervision by the state courts and state constitutions.
The theory, known as the "independent state legislature theory," stems from the election clause in Article I of the Constitution. It says, "The times, places and manner of holding elections for senators and representatives, shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof."
Proponents of the theory argue that that clause gives state legislatures power to regulate federal elections uninhibited by state courts or state constitutions. If a majority of the Supreme Court agrees, that would hamstring state courts, removing judicial oversight of state elections.
Spearthrower wrote:I agree - it's an impossible situation.
The idea of simply adding to the SC to get the outcome you want is a terrible precedent.
On the other hand, this generation has to deal with carbon induced climate change else future generations will pay dearly for our failures.
Ugh, we stupid fucking monkeys just can't get our acts together.
I am sure there always were counter forces in every golden age, and the power and dramatic effect of this may mean the counter forces end up being just as powerful and dramatic.
The_Piper wrote:Spearthrower wrote:I agree - it's an impossible situation.
The idea of simply adding to the SC to get the outcome you want is a terrible precedent.
On the other hand, this generation has to deal with carbon induced climate change else future generations will pay dearly for our failures.
Ugh, we stupid fucking monkeys just can't get our acts together.
I am sure there always were counter forces in every golden age, and the power and dramatic effect of this may mean the counter forces end up being just as powerful and dramatic.
I heard court expansion rationalized like this (I think it was Beau of the Fifth Column) - If Dems add justices we can stem the bleeding right now, and if Republicans add more when they are in power, we're right back where we started. In other words, the worst case scenario is already happening right now. I can't think of a better idea. I like the idea ofa large supreme court because any one justice's vote won't have so much weight, it dilutes their power.
chango369 wrote:Judicial coup in progress.The Supreme Court on Thursday agreed to hear a case that could dramatically change how federal elections are conducted. At issue is a legal theory that would give state legislatures unfettered authority to set the rules for federal elections, free of supervision by the state courts and state constitutions.
The theory, known as the "independent state legislature theory," stems from the election clause in Article I of the Constitution. It says, "The times, places and manner of holding elections for senators and representatives, shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof."
Proponents of the theory argue that that clause gives state legislatures power to regulate federal elections uninhibited by state courts or state constitutions. If a majority of the Supreme Court agrees, that would hamstring state courts, removing judicial oversight of state elections.
NPR: Supreme Court to take on controversial election-law case
It’s based on biblical literalism, a fundamentalist Christian fanatical movement.
We’re being hurled back decades, if not centuries, to be honest,” Das said, later adding: “They’re really trying to transform society to one that’s dominated on the basis of white supremacy, male supremacy, Christian supremacy. It’s very dangerous.
The decision to side with polluters over the public will cost American lives and cause an enormous amount of preventable suffering, with the biggest burden falling on low-income communities and communities of color,
Robert P Jones, founder and chief executive of the Public Religion Research Institute thinktank in Washington, said: “What we’re seeing is a desperate power grab as the sun is setting on white Christian America. In the courts, instead of moving slowly and systematically, it’s a lurch.”
Jones added: “In the meantime we’re going to be left with essentially an apartheid situation in the US where we’re going to have minority rule by this shrinking group that’s been able to seize the levers of power, even as their cultural democratic representation in the country shrinks.”
Rachel Laser, president of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, which represented the school board in the case, said the separation was “under complete attack” by the supreme court as it favours the free exercise clause at the expense of the establishment clause, thereby raising the specter of religious favoritism.
“We are at risk of taking away the religious freedom of vast numbers of Americans, which should make the founders of our country be doing somersaults in their grave and I’m sure is alarming to the world as a whole, because they see America as a beacon of light when it comes to religious freedom.”
“This is a backlash that is meant to reinforce and cement existing power structures into our law, and it panders to a white Christian right extremist agenda. It’s incredibly divisive. It’s dangerous to our democracy in that regard.”
What we’re seeing is a desperate power grab as the sun is setting on white Christian America.
Tortured_Genius wrote:To be fair, the Screaming Jesus Clown Posse are mainly a tool of people who have about as many sincere religious convictions as the Borgias.
Ironically, long term they may well find themselves having to deal with an inconvenient mass of cultists who would rather burn witches and live in log cabins than enrich their political masters. Unfortunately for everyone else, I can see the parasites just siphoning off what little can be salvaged from the dying corpse whilst they fuck off to their billionaires playground of choice.
Return to News, Politics & Current Affairs
Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 1 guest