Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

Richard Dawkins on politics

For discussion of politics, and what's going on in the world today.

Moderators: Darkchilde, Mazille, Durro, Weaver, Fallible, HughMcB, byofrcs

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

 
 

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#121  Postby Nicko » Nov 02, 2010 10:38 am

THWOTH wrote: When a big kid comes into the playground with a stick in his hand and starts thwacking and making demands then I'm all for picking up a stick and teaching them a lesson, there is no good reason why everybody else should put up with that kind of anti-social behaviour - but who actually has the biggest stick in the playground here, and is keen to use it to get exactly what they want? Eh?


When considering US foriegn policy, I'm always reminded of the old saying (Japanese, I think):

To a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.
"Everyone’s worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there’s really an easy way: Stop participating in it."
— Noam Chomsky

Please read this before asserting a supernatural explanation for anything.
User avatar
Nicko
 
Name: Nick Williams
Posts: 2330
Age: 35
Male

Country: Australia
Australia (au)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#122  Postby THWOTH » Nov 02, 2010 10:41 am

Nicko wrote:
THWOTH wrote: When a big kid comes into the playground with a stick in his hand and starts thwacking and making demands then I'm all for picking up a stick and teaching them a lesson, there is no good reason why everybody else should put up with that kind of anti-social behaviour - but who actually has the biggest stick in the playground here, and is keen to use it to get exactly what they want? Eh?


When considering US foriegn policy, I'm always reminded of the old saying (Japanese, I think):

To a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.

:D Yeah. What's the point of wielding a big stick if you're not going to use it? As if the weaponry authorises its own use... :doh:
...drink coffee - live long...

Image
Image
User avatar
THWOTH
RS Donator
 
Name: Penrose
Posts: 16524
Age: 47

Country: ConDemNation
European Union (eur)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#123  Postby trubble76 » Nov 02, 2010 11:29 am

Terry Rotter wrote:It's like talking to Christians. You live in some sort of parallel universe that works entirely differently compared to mine. Simply useless. I just hope that you are very untypical secularists and leave it at that.


If anyone was wondering what a dummy (pacifier for you colonials) being spat out looks like in text form...
“I never say that evolution is a fact. Evolution is a theory. It's much more important than a fact, because theories explain things.” Eugenie Scott
User avatar
trubble76
RS Donator
 
Posts: 6573
Age: 35
Male

United Kingdom (uk)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#124  Postby Terry Rotter » Nov 02, 2010 11:37 am

Alright, one further remark: We should ultimately bring down every dictatorship. But we can obviously not just attack countries like Saudi Arabia and Pakistan that claim to be our allys and at least to some degree behave like it. It would be more effective to make them adopt human rights. I they don't comply, we will see what to do about it. Also, we can not fight every dictatorship at once. Of course strategy has to be a part of it, too. We should't go around and blindly attack everyone, that's just silly, no one thinks this.

The US has the greatest military power in the world. With great power comes great responsibility. Did Spiderman teach you nothing?

The comments from some of you about Israel were absolutely disgusting and anti-semitic.

THWOTH wrote:totalitarian death cults having them unless they're nominally liberal and a friend of America called Israel

It is simply beyond belief. Nothing about Israel is anything like a totalitarian death cult. It is factually a liberal democracy with equal rights for Jews, Muslims, Christians, everyone. The fact that it is a Jewish state results from 2000 years of pogroms against Jews. It is their sanctuary. And you call it a "death cult"! Who was your teacher? Hitler? Because this is the exact same kind of stuff we get to hear from the German Nazi parties.

Nicko wrote:If you define it as a religion, then it is as much a "liberal democracy" as any Islamic Republic that happens to hold a popularity contest every couple of years

You have no idea what you're talking about. I just hope you don't go around and burn down synagogues because they are too religious for you.

Fucking awful. You just hide anti-semitism behind an antitheist mask. To just equate everything remotely religious to Islamic terrorists is truly insane and beyond all responsibility.
Last edited by Terry Rotter on Nov 02, 2010 11:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
Terry Rotter
THREAD STARTER
 
Posts: 22

Country: Germany
Germany (de)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#125  Postby Festeringbob » Nov 02, 2010 11:39 am

wow, i call poe, no honest person would post such a senseless diatribe
Liberty Prime is online. All systems nominal. Weapons hot. Mission: the destruction of any and all Chinese communists.
User avatar
Festeringbob
 
Posts: 2626
Age: 25
Male

Australia (au)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#126  Postby NineOneFour » Nov 02, 2010 11:46 am

Festeringbob wrote:wow, i call poe, no honest person would post such a senseless diatribe


You've never been to Texas, have you, Bob?
I'm out of here until the leadership or rules of this forum are overhauled.

Those of you who want to hang with me, go here: http://iamnineonefour.tumblr.com
Those of you who don't, get rammed.
NineOneFour
 
Posts: 18501
Age: 42
Male

Country: Texas: the f-you state
Jolly Roger (arr)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#127  Postby NineOneFour » Nov 02, 2010 11:52 am

Terry Rotter wrote:Alright, one further remark: We should ultimately bring down every dictatorship. But we can obviously not just attack countries like Saudi Arabia and Pakistan that claim to be our allys and at least to some degree behave like it. It would be more effective to make them adopt human rights. I they don't comply, we will see what to do about it. Also, we can not fight every dictatorship at once. Of course strategy has to be a part of it, too. We should't go around and blindly attack everyone, that's just silly, no one thinks this.


We can't even handle Afghanistan and Iraq and it's taken 10 years to pacify them and you think we can systematically bring down every dictatorship? The US military is not that powerful and we don't have those kinds of numbers in personnel.

The US has the greatest military power in the world.


Is this overcompensation for something or what? I don't think we need the greatest military power in the world, just enough to stop anyone from attacking us. What you want is to go on the offense, and that is deeply aberrant to our entire history pre-2003.

With great power comes great responsibility. Did Spiderman teach you nothing?


Some of us get our political philosophy from places other than comic books. However, I agree with the message, and that is why we have a responsibility to first do no harm. We also have a responsibility to take care of our own citizens first before we go blundering about the world, a fact that seems blissfully lost on you.

The comments from some of you about Israel were absolutely disgusting and anti-semitic.

THWOTH wrote:totalitarian death cults having them unless they're nominally liberal and a friend of America called Israel

It is simply beyond belief. Nothing about Israel is anything like a totalitarian death cult. It is factually a liberal democracy with equal rights for Jews, Muslims, Christians, everyone. The fact that it is a Jewish state results from 2000 years of pogroms against Jews. It is their sanctuary. And you call it a "death cult"! Who was your teacher? Hitler? Because this is the exact same kind of stuff we get to hear from the German Nazi parties.


Image

Nicko wrote:If you define it as a religion, then it is as much a "liberal democracy" as any Islamic Republic that happens to hold a popularity contest every couple of years

You have no idea what you're talking about. I just hope you don't go around and burn down synagogues because they are too religious for you.


No, thanks, atheists tend to leave the destruction of other people's property to the zealots, by which I mean Christians, Muslims, neoconservatives.

Fucking awful.


I don't know as I'd go that far in describing your philosophy...

You just hide anti-semitism behind an antitheist mask. To just equate everything remotely religious to Islamic terrorists is truly insane and beyond all responsibility.


Why?

Ask George Tiller if Christian terrorists are any less deadly.

Oh, and you still haven't noticed that 180,000 Americans died of no health care while you were happily trumpeting American "successes" overseas from 2001-2010. Which should come first: a War on Terror to avenge 3000 dead Americans or a War on Poverty to avenge 180,000 dead Americans?
I'm out of here until the leadership or rules of this forum are overhauled.

Those of you who want to hang with me, go here: http://iamnineonefour.tumblr.com
Those of you who don't, get rammed.
NineOneFour
 
Posts: 18501
Age: 42
Male

Country: Texas: the f-you state
Jolly Roger (arr)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#128  Postby Thommo » Nov 02, 2010 12:01 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:The US has the greatest military power in the world. With great power comes great responsibility. Did Spiderman teach you nothing?


Oh man, you totally missed the point of that film.

Spiderman had to learn when not to use his powers as well as when to use them. Remember why uncle Ben gave him that speech? Because he beat up a bully at school.

When spiderman tried to impose his will on others by letting the criminal go and adopting this "eye for an eye" policy poor uncle Ben got killed, it was only when he instead risked himself to protect the innocent that he was truly a hero. Peter Parker learned his lesson the hard way, I just hope you don't have to as well.
Everything in moderation, even moderation.
Thommo
 
Posts: 6576


Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#129  Postby THWOTH » Nov 02, 2010 12:24 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:
THWOTH wrote:totalitarian death cults having them [nuclear weapons] unless they're nominally liberal and a friend of America called Israel

It is simply beyond belief. Nothing about Israel is anything like a totalitarian death cult. It is factually a liberal democracy with equal rights for Jews, Muslims, Christians, everyone. The fact that it is a Jewish state results from 2000 years of pogroms against Jews. It is their sanctuary. And you call it a "death cult"! Who was your teacher? Hitler? Because this is the exact same kind of stuff we get to hear from the German Nazi parties.

Very good. You should put a smiley on that so that we can tell it was meant as a joke. :D

What is not totalitarian about a theocracy? Israel is a putative theocracy, perhaps one might even say a de facto theocracy. As for a 'death cult,' well I think a religion which holds that one is obliged to do the bidding of Yaweh, whatever that is deemed to be by whatever self-declared authority, or else suffer a smitin' qualifies as a death cult I think.

As for referring to me personally as a Nazi, well, if you weren't joking then simple apology will suffice there.

Is it the act of a reasonable State to deny the very existence of their nuclear weapons in order that they may circumvent and abrogate the responsibilities they would otherwise have under international agreements and understandings?

I'm sure you can guess my views on Israel's big-stick-behind-my-back approach to relations with its immediate, and not so immediate neighbours, but what's yours?
...drink coffee - live long...

Image
Image
User avatar
THWOTH
RS Donator
 
Name: Penrose
Posts: 16524
Age: 47

Country: ConDemNation
European Union (eur)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#130  Postby Daan » Nov 02, 2010 12:43 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:The US has the greatest military power in the world. With great power comes great responsibility. Did Spiderman teach you nothing?


The army is being paid by money lend from China. It is not sustainable anymore to have such a large army. America will have to cooperate with other countries to secure human rights.
Daan
 
Posts: 1481
Age: 33
Male


Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#131  Postby Terry Rotter » Nov 02, 2010 12:47 pm

I didn't refer to you as a Nazi. I said that the German Nazi parties (NPD and Die Republikaner) say very similar things about Israel than you say. This is an empirical fact that I can easily prove.

In a Nazi protest in July 2006 50 NPD members including chairman Udo Voigt called Israel the "Internationale Völkermordzentrale" (International Genocide Centre). The Nazis believe that "Israel will zusammen mit den angeblich von Juden kontrollierten USA - die Welt versklaven" (Israel wants to enslave the world together with the USA that is supposedly controlled by the Jews). Especially the neocons are supposed to be at the centre of the Zionist-Jewish conspiracy for world dominance. NPD-Frakionschef Holger Apfel called Israel a "jüdischer Schurkenstaat" (Jewish rogue state). These statements are generally considered to be anti-semitic in Germany and in fact, the Nazis got arrested and imprisoned for making such statements because that counts as "Volksverhetzung" among others.
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existenzre ... d_Parteien
http://www.shortnews.de/id/836694/Dresd ... urkenstaat

How about apologizing to the Jews for calling their country totalitarian and a death cult?
Terry Rotter
THREAD STARTER
 
Posts: 22

Country: Germany
Germany (de)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#132  Postby trubble76 » Nov 02, 2010 12:49 pm

Israel is a liberal democracy? Bwahahahaha!! :lol:

I'm glad I popped in.
“I never say that evolution is a fact. Evolution is a theory. It's much more important than a fact, because theories explain things.” Eugenie Scott
User avatar
trubble76
RS Donator
 
Posts: 6573
Age: 35
Male

United Kingdom (uk)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#133  Postby Nicko » Nov 02, 2010 12:52 pm

Ah, the standard response to criticism of Israel. How original.

Nicko wrote:If you define it as a religion, then it is as much a "liberal democracy" as any Islamic Republic that happens to hold a popularity contest every couple of years

You have no idea what you're talking about. I just hope you don't go around and burn down synagogues because they are too religious for you.

Fucking awful. You just hide anti-semitism behind an antitheist mask. To just equate everything remotely religious to Islamic terrorists is truly insane and beyond all responsibility.


How exactly is pointing out that a state that defines itself as "Jewish" is no more a "Liberal Democracy" than a state that defines itself as "Islamic" count as equating "everything remotely religious to Islamic terrorists"? You are aware that not all Muslims are terrorists, aren't you? Or even Jihadis/Mujahadeen? Or even fundamentalist? No one with an ounce of sense, however, thinks that a country that privleges Islam over all other religions qualifies as a liberal democracy. I am simply applying the rule across the board.

As far as the anti semitism goes, you don't know what the fuck you are talking about.

Which is kind of a thing with you, isn't it?

I'll give you some genuine advice regarding politics and the original topic of this thread, though. People always say that their motives are good. I can think of a bloke from around your way who once insisted that Poland posed an immanent danger to your country. A pre-emptive strike was obviously neccessary.

Six decades later, no one gives a fuck what the prick said. They look at what the prick did.

Start looking now.
"Everyone’s worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there’s really an easy way: Stop participating in it."
— Noam Chomsky

Please read this before asserting a supernatural explanation for anything.
User avatar
Nicko
 
Name: Nick Williams
Posts: 2330
Age: 35
Male

Country: Australia
Australia (au)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#134  Postby Terry Rotter » Nov 02, 2010 12:58 pm

To critizise Israel is not a problem, to compare it to an Islamic theocracy and call it a "death cult" is absurd beyond all comparison. How about I just call Britain or Australia a "death cult", makes equally much sense. But everyone would call this insane.

Well, you can easily inform yourself about Israel and the conflict with Palestine.
http://markhumphrys.com/israel.conflict.html
Terry Rotter
THREAD STARTER
 
Posts: 22

Country: Germany
Germany (de)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#135  Postby mrjonno » Nov 02, 2010 12:59 pm

How about apologizing to the Jews for calling their country totalitarian and a death cult?


The very fact you link Jews to Israel shows you how racist the apartheid based state is. Saying a country is for people of a particular faith automatically kills dead any claim that Israel is a democracy
Why bother being an islamic suicide bomber to get 72 virgins in heaven when you can be a Catholic priest and get them on Earth (Jimmy Carr)
User avatar
mrjonno
 
Posts: 6737
Age: 40
Male

United Kingdom (uk)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#136  Postby Terry Rotter » Nov 02, 2010 1:21 pm

No, it does not. Israel is the refuge of the Jews because they have been persecuted everywhere. It is policy to keep a majority of Israelis ethnically Jewish because the Palestinians want to dissolve Israel and subvert the Jews as soon as they become a majority in Israel as they had done before 1948. However, those Christians, Muslims and everyone else who lives there have equal rights. In fact, there even are Muslim politicians in Israel who want Israel to be destroyed. And most of the Jews in Israel are secular. You are terribly uninformed and you repeat ideas of the very worst sort of people there are.
Terry Rotter
THREAD STARTER
 
Posts: 22

Country: Germany
Germany (de)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#137  Postby mrjonno » Nov 02, 2010 1:30 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:No, it does not. Israel is the refuge of the Jews because they have been persecuted everywhere. It is policy to keep a majority of Israelis ethnically Jewish because the Palestinians want to dissolve Israel and subvert the Jews as soon as they become a majority in Israel as they had done before 1948. However, those Christians, Muslims and everyone else who lives there have equal rights. In fact, there even are Muslim politicians in Israel who want Israel to be destroyed. And most of the Jews in Israel are secular. You are terribly uninformed and you repeat ideas of the very worst sort of people there are.


None of what you have said above supports Israel being a democracy, being persecuted doesnt make you a democracy, Palestinians not liking Israeli/Jews doesnt make you a democracy. There is a reason for religion being put on your passport/identity card in Israel and its not because 'everyone is treated equally'. Some Jews in Israel are secular some arent but biblical law is the law in many areas of Israeli life.

Of course none of this makes any of the Arab countries democracies either but the big difference is the US doesnt pour billions of pounds of military aid in them and basically economically prop up the entire regime. (generally due to christian fundies in the US ( the real threat) wanting Armageddon)

A decent Israeli /Palestinian settlement would be the biggest factor in reducing Islamic terrorism in the world. I doubt if it would eliminate it entirely but the world would be a hell of a lot safer afterwards
Why bother being an islamic suicide bomber to get 72 virgins in heaven when you can be a Catholic priest and get them on Earth (Jimmy Carr)
User avatar
mrjonno
 
Posts: 6737
Age: 40
Male

United Kingdom (uk)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#138  Postby Terry Rotter » Nov 02, 2010 1:41 pm

It is a representative democracy, that is the political system of Israel! Human rights are guaranteed and people, including Muslims, elect their leaders. Nothing like this could be said of any Muslim country nearby.
Terry Rotter
THREAD STARTER
 
Posts: 22

Country: Germany
Germany (de)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#139  Postby trubble76 » Nov 02, 2010 1:45 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:It is a representative democracy, that is the political system of Israel! Human rights are guaranteed and people, including Muslims, elect their leaders. Nothing like this could be said of any Muslim country nearby.



More jokes, excellent. Do you know any Essex Girls funnies?
“I never say that evolution is a fact. Evolution is a theory. It's much more important than a fact, because theories explain things.” Eugenie Scott
User avatar
trubble76
RS Donator
 
Posts: 6573
Age: 35
Male

United Kingdom (uk)

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

 
 

Re: Why Dawkins is wrong on politics

#140  Postby Festeringbob » Nov 02, 2010 1:55 pm

Terry Rotter wrote:It is a representative democracy, that is the political system of Israel! Human rights are guaranteed and people, including Muslims, elect their leaders. Nothing like this could be said of any Muslim country nearby.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maurice_Motamed
Liberty Prime is online. All systems nominal. Weapons hot. Mission: the destruction of any and all Chinese communists.
User avatar
Festeringbob
 
Posts: 2626
Age: 25
Male

Australia (au)

PreviousNext

Return to News, Politics & Current Affairs

Who is online

Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 1 guest