So today the Tories tried *really* hard to end the union, in a staggering display of idiocy. Their rushed and incoherent English Votes for English Laws proposals, a huge change to the consitution, is not being done through legislation but by a change to the Standing Orders of the Commons, with the poor speaker expected to decide what constitutes a law which only certain members of the house can now decide on.
So laws for England/E&Wales only areas which are currently devolved to Wales Northern Ireland or Scotland will require English MP's to pass, with those MP's from other parts of the country excluded. Sounds fine to me, except many decisions will affect the funding which leads to funding changes to the devolved administrations. By contrast, decisions made in Wales Scotland and NI don't affect the funding in England. Naturally, this oddity won't apply to London MP's who will still be able to vote on other English transport etc even though they have no ability to affect London transport policy which is made by the Mayor.
For the last week the Tories have prevented any amendments to the Scotland Bill, when 58 of the 59 Scottish MP's voted for them, most not even listening to the debates just being wheeled out the bars to vote each time. Um ...
English votes for English Laws, English votes for Scottish/Welsh/NI Laws. EVELEVSWNIL. Catchy.
If EVEL is about "fairness", Mr Cameron, I presume we'll be getting all of the following...1) The Scottish Parliament will be granted the power to unilaterally abolish the Westminster Parliament, as long as 61% of MSPs vote in favour of doing so. This equalises the current situation whereby 326 out of 533 English MPs (61%) can unilaterally abolish the Scottish Parliament at any time, even if every single Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish MP votes against. If it makes the London press feel any happier, we can always put a meaningless platitude into the legislation about how "it is recognised that the Westminster Parliament is a permanent part of our constitutional arrangements, as long as we stay in a good mood".
2) The Scottish Parliament will be granted the power to veto any constitutional changes affecting England, provided that 61% of MSPs vote for the veto. Loud cheering is strongly encouraged. This equalises the current situation whereby English MPs were able to veto Full Fiscal Autonomy for Scotland on Monday night, even though 95% of Scottish MPs voted in favour of it.
.... and more.