Posted: Aug 27, 2021 2:52 pm
by newolder
Physicists Debate Hawking’s Idea That the Universe Had No Beginning is the title of a "good read" Quanta Magazine article by Natalie Wolchover from 2019 that brought the Hartle-Hawking/Neil Turok* et al debate to no kind of resolution...
...
No matter how things go, perhaps we’ll be left with some essence of the picture Hawking first painted at the Pontifical Academy of Sciences 38 years ago. Or perhaps, instead of a South Pole-like non-beginning, the universe emerged from a singularity after all, demanding a different kind of wave function altogether. Either way, the pursuit will continue. “If we are talking about a quantum mechanical theory, what else is there to find other than the wave function?” asked Juan Maldacena, an eminent theoretical physicist at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey, who has mostly stayed out of the recent fray. The question of the wave function of the universe “is the right kind of question to ask,” said Maldacena, who, incidentally, is a member of the Pontifical Academy. “Whether we are finding the right wave function, or how we should think about the wave function — it’s less clear.”

Much fun.

* e.g. "No smooth beginning for spacetime", Job Feldbrugge, Jean-Luc Lehners, Neil Turok arXiv link