Posted: May 17, 2012 3:01 pm
by rEvolutionist
amkerman wrote:Shrinks argument is:

1. If god exists he is something which cannot exist. (not valid)


How do you know, in this example, that he can't exist? A premise is it's own entity in a logic statement. It's validity as a premise is not contingent upon any other premises. That's how deductive logic works.