Posted: May 17, 2012 3:39 pm
Shrunk wrote:rEvolutionist wrote:Why am I being ignored? And why is my god = a carrot argument not being taken seriously?
To be honest, it's not exactly structured as an argument, is it?
If we say "God is a carrot", we are already stating that God exists, carrots exist (or at least one carrot does) and God is a carrot. So I don't really think the 2nd premise and conclusion add anything.
Exactly. Now if only we could get Amkerman to understand that about his version, then we could put this thread to bed!