Posted: May 18, 2012 8:08 am
by Thommo
amkerman wrote:This is the last I will comment on the subject. If you still disagree we seem to be at an impasse. No hard feelings.

Given that you've conceded the point, I can't see why there would be. ;)
amkerman wrote:If it's god, then it's a square circle
It's not a square circle
Therefore, it's not god


In classical logic the former argument is valid

Obviously this was the exact opposite of your earlier repeated declarations on this matter, so it seems we've fixed the misunderstanding. :thumbup: