Posted: Oct 22, 2021 7:08 am
by Spearthrower
Stein wrote:
Spearthrower wrote:I think it's perfectly possible to acknowledge the atrocious actions of the Israeli state without even momentarily thinking to blame Jews en masse. I also think that this transparently specious false dilemma has been erected so many times now as a smoke-screen, it's worthy of being considered hackneyed.

Once one adopts the blatant double standard of advocating for a state for the Palestinians but not one for the Israelis, that is antisemitic. One sauce for the goose but another for the gander! That's a blatant one-way street right out of David Duke. Only sophistry rationalizes something that blatant as free of plain old bigotry. Tell me another.


Which part of what I wrote suggests that I don't accept the Israeli state?

You've projected that onto what I wrote and then called it antisemitic and then likened me to being a leader of the KKK.

Frankly, this corroborates what I was saying. It's such a transparently specious false dilemma, you have to make up a load of bullshit out of thin air to maintain it.