Posted: Sep 23, 2013 6:52 pm
by tolman
Could easily have been a 'fan' given an early copy.

Not particularly relevant anyway, since even if you knew they existed, someone who has only posted one review would be pretty suspect even for a non-contentious product where the producer had some record for producing quality stuff.
When it comes to an area like Creationism and ID which is populated with ignoramuses, delusionals and liars, much more caution regarding reviews would be in order.
I wouldn't put it past some people to have sock-puppet negative strawman reviews which some other reviewer can then tear apart to show how horrible those evils scientists are.