Posted: Oct 19, 2010 1:00 pm
tnjrp wrote:I for one am not exceedingly convinced by Sheldrake's studies. Those unpleasantly skeptical people Wiseman, Smith and Milton for example rained rather heavily on his parade about Jaytee, the psychic dog. Not sure if either Mr. Wiseman or Mr. Smith sported a goatee at the time of their studies on the said canine.
Wiseman's arguments on Jaytee were however completely spurious- a fact discussed in an article by a third party in the latest JSPR. I'll text Matthew now and ask him his opinion of the Jaytee affair, and if he still holds his and Wiseman's critique was correct. Matthew did not have a goatee back then as far as I know - he must have been barely out of short trousers, but I think Richard did have.
j x