Posted: Jan 13, 2018 5:16 pm
by newolder
DavidMcC wrote:
newolder wrote:
DavidMcC wrote:...
You need to read Lee Smolin on quantum loop gravity, not wikipedia, which is not good on this particular subject. ...

If it is difficult to attribute and quote the relevant section(s), I'll pass, thanks.

I'm not asking you to do that,

That's the first correct thing you've posted. :thumbup:
However, I am asking you to find, post and attribute the relevant info.
just find what he wrote about LQG, up to the point when he declared that he must be wrong, but for spurious reasons (relating to the number of generations of universes being assumed (incorrectly, IMO) to be so large that there would be some kind of natural selection acting on them, by analogy with biological NS (which, of course DOES involve a very large number of generations).

Bracketting error, logic fail, bait and switch - all noted.

Why are you ignoring Thommo's posts in this topic?