Posted: May 30, 2015 10:24 pm
by Jerome Da Gnome
Onyx8 wrote:I can understand it, you're just wrong. Where does it say he was lying?


Because we already know how Saul died. The Amalekite was trying to endear himself to David by saying he mercy killed Saul and brought his gear to David as evidence, when we already know this is not true.

Again, the text reporting someone lying is not the text lying.

Do you have any text where it states the words of the Amalekite are infallible?