Posted: Jul 09, 2010 10:53 am
1) Seems a bit unbalanced somehow
2) I don't like the quasi-mathematical thing. Rational to the power of scepticism just doesn't make any mathematical sense, which means it's nonsense, which is precisely what rational scepticism is supposed to avoid.
3) I don't see a point to the mirror-image thing
5) I think it looks a bit weird having the Earth rolling around a Möbius strip, and although I've read the explanation of what it's about, I don't think the connection's immediate obvious.
7) I don't like the highlighted letters 'a' and 'sk'. Though rational scepticism might be about asking, it isn't so on the strength of having the letters 'a' and 'sk' in it, any more than God is about good orderly direction because you can make an anagram out of it or some such. And outside of America, it's spelt 'scepticism', so it doesn't even have 'sk' in it.
8) I don't see any particular reason why 'rational' should be sideways
9) This one's too cute for me, and I think it would be better to use the primary web address
12) as for 1
13) as for 7
14) This one feels arrogant
15) as for 2
That leaves 4, 6, 10 and 11, and since I'm only allowed 3 votes, I'll strategically vote for the 3 that have the most votes at the moment.
2) I don't like the quasi-mathematical thing. Rational to the power of scepticism just doesn't make any mathematical sense, which means it's nonsense, which is precisely what rational scepticism is supposed to avoid.
3) I don't see a point to the mirror-image thing
5) I think it looks a bit weird having the Earth rolling around a Möbius strip, and although I've read the explanation of what it's about, I don't think the connection's immediate obvious.
7) I don't like the highlighted letters 'a' and 'sk'. Though rational scepticism might be about asking, it isn't so on the strength of having the letters 'a' and 'sk' in it, any more than God is about good orderly direction because you can make an anagram out of it or some such. And outside of America, it's spelt 'scepticism', so it doesn't even have 'sk' in it.
8) I don't see any particular reason why 'rational' should be sideways
9) This one's too cute for me, and I think it would be better to use the primary web address
12) as for 1
13) as for 7
14) This one feels arrogant
15) as for 2
That leaves 4, 6, 10 and 11, and since I'm only allowed 3 votes, I'll strategically vote for the 3 that have the most votes at the moment.