Posted: Jul 27, 2011 9:01 am
pinkharrier wrote:THWOTH wrote; You're saying there is a specific Jewish political agenda, a specifically Jewish attitude?
To immigration to Israel? Yes, and it is official (although, no doubt, some would be critical). The point is I don't see too many up in arms because of it, least of all you. Does that mean you give tacit support to a "Jews only" immigration policy to Israel? So I don't feel distressed and any group (including whites) can have their own preferences. I do have a problem when any group can except whites.
You've created a fallacious comparison between members of a religion and people with a certain skin colour there. Israel is a Theocracy in all but name, and Theocracies are predicated on the religious conformity of the population - surely this is not a surprise to you, nor the implications it might have for Israel's domestic and foreign policy? Of course not, you're just using the example to whine that Whites are not being afforded the rights, privileges and/or protection accrued by other groups. This really does need some support to be credible - I won't hold my breath. How distressed are you when any group's 'preference' involves excluding, removing, or otherwise discriminating against non-group members?
Are you going to demonstrate some of that intellectual honesty you bemoan is lacking in the discussion and address those outstanding points?