Posted: Aug 17, 2014 1:23 pm
by Pulsar
t5aylor wrote:Well what, in your mind, would make him a scientist?

Publications in peer-reviewed journals.

t5aylor wrote:Einstein was a patent clerk when he wrote his best stuff.

Which he published in scientific journals.

t5aylor wrote:I was hoping to find someone who can criticize his work, not google his alma mater.

If he has something relevant to say, he should publish it in peer-reviewed journals. That's where scientific ideas are evaluated. Anything else is not worth addressing.