felltoearth wrote:Interesting choice of words–Mind.
I totally missed this, sorry.
So, wortfish, let's have it. You're really here stumping for the existence of a soul aren't you? Some incorporeal essence of us that is somehow immortal.
You're going to have to do much better than not dead people claiming to be dead people and remembering a bit of the experience. I want to see an isolated soul. Catch one. Let's communicate with it. Shouldn't be a big trick to set up a test to demonstrate if the one you caught is actually a soul of who you claim it to be. If I had my own forum such as this, I would have one rule about this. Demonstrate the existence of souls or shut up and leave (or be shown the exit if they can't do either).
All the rest of this supernatural rubbish is predicated on the concept of a soul. Without that, there's no need at all for the rest.