Calilasseia wrote:Interesting that this ribozyme works using Mg
2+ ions. Aside from the fact that there are 1.3 grams of magnesium dissolved in every litre of seawater (source:
Kaye & Laby's Tables of Physical & Chemical Constants), a rich source of magnesium ions is, wait for it ... montmorillonite clays. Which have been a staple substrate for abiogenesis research for something like two decades.
In fact, not just two decades. Claymineral crystals were hypothesized to be of fundamental importance for the origin of life by none other than Alexander Graham Cairns Smith, all the way back in the
1960's.
And not just because of their later discovered catalytic properties for much of organic chemistry. Cairns Smith envisioned the clay crystals as essentially the first genetic system, where growth of crystals was analogous to genetic replication, and where replication of growth defects was analogous to mutations in daughter genes(changing/increasing information).
http://originoflife.net/A lot of interesting reading on that hypothesis there, I would recommend it to anyone.
Unfortunately, it's not a hypothesis that has been subjected to much experimental testing at all. There are a few papers around on the information-transfering fidelities in crystal growth, based on testing parts of his hypothesis, but the results are inconclusive(as in not confirming nor ruling out the hypothesis), and they didn't use clay crystals as their test-subject-genes[1]. But what I find very fascinating about it is the constant findings in contemporary OOL research that somehow relate to various catalytic properties of mineral crystals, usually clays and montmorillonite in particular. One can't deny that AG Cairns-Smith was on to something.
[1]
Test of Cairns-Smith’s ‘crystals-as-genes’ hypothesishttps://depts.washington.edu/ntuf/facility/docs/b616612c.pdf Abstract
One aspect of the multifaceted proposal by A. G. Cairns-Smith, that imperfect crystals have the capacity to act as primitive genes by transferring the disposition of their imperfections from one crystal to another, is investigated. Rather than examining clay minerals, the most likely crystalline genes in the theories of Cairns-Smith, an experiment was designed in a model crystalline system unrelated to the composition of the prebiotic earth but suited to a well-defined test. Plates of potassium hydrogen phthalate riddled with dislocations were studied in order to ascertain whether, according to Cairns-Smith, parallel screw dislocations could serve as an information store with cores akin to punches in an old computer card. Evidence of screw dislocations was obtained from their associated growth hillocks through differential interference contrast microscopy, atomic force microscopy, and luminescence labeling of hillocks in conjunction with confocal laser scanning microscopy. The dispositions of growth active hillocks were quantified by fractal analysis. ‘Mother’ crystals were cleaved and inheritance was evaluated by the corresponding patterns of luminescence developed in their ‘daughters’ after continued growth in the presence of fluorophores. Luminescence microscopy proves to be a versatile tool for studying the dynamics of growth active hillocks. In the aggregate, this work speaks to the need for molecular mechanisms of dislocation nucleation.