I wouldn't know how to plan a lesson for someone else, but all I could suggest is that
doing stuff is more interesting than
listening to stuff.
Conceiving of a way to 'show' how change accrues over time would be more stimulating - even better would be to have them doing something that showed this.
Perhaps - and this is just as a suggestion as it would require quite some work on your part, you could find a series of photos of skulls showing the evolution of, say, horses, whales, cats and humans, or other well documented fossil records, and then mix them all up. Have as many complete piles as desired small groups, split them into groups and have them try to match up the correct groups of species together. This will be extremely easy - and that's part of the point.
Get them to explain how they did it - have some of the labels for various distinctive parts of skull morphology ready to help them talk about it - i.e. temporal bone, mandible etc so they can say 'the mandible's bigger' or whatever.
Then once achieved try to see if they can determine a chronological order. This will be considerably harder in some cases, but they should get some of it right. Much congratulations - they're anatomists!
Again, try to draw out their reasoning for their ordering - it doesn't matter whether they're right or wrong here. Then ask what it means for a species to change over time and bob's your uncle, you can go onto the history of human attempts to explain diversity.
What this is showing is one way by which the notion of evolution can be alighted on - by the tracks of descent through anatomy.
It's a rough idea, but something like it should produce a lot of questions and interest.