quas wrote:Forgot to give the proper link:
http://www.fantastic-voyage.net/ReaderQ ... m#alkalineScholasticSpastic wrote:I sincerely hope you're not serious about this idiot. Alkaline water isn't oxygen reductive period. Not with soap. Not with baking soda. Not with naturally occurring minerals from the spring between Minerva's thighs. Not anywhere at all.
Kurzweil has said that soap/baking soda water is not oxygen reductive. Water that contains minerals in it, can be ionised (in a process similar to electrolysis?) such that it becomes alkaline water that is oxygen reductive.
So what? Why should I care what Kurzweil says about chemistry when I have several big fucking chemistry textbooks which counter his claims?
The autodissociation of water is an interesting thing. Learn about it. Please understand that water doesn't care what proton acceptor you add to it, the result is the same. Drop in some lye, or some MgO, or some baking soda and you get exactly the same fucking anion: OH-. So any claim about the selectivity of the process by which anions in water are derived is going to be bullshit to the same extent that homeopathy is bullshit. All bases everywhere are identical in terms of capacity to produce OH- in aqueous systems (this is not a claim that all bases will produce the same number of molar equivalencies of OH-, it's a claim that OH- is the anion they produce). I suppose we could move into organic-phase solvent systems where some really cool shit becomes possible, but I would advise against drinking organic solvents.
At least, not any more so than anything else with an abundance of negative charge.
Such as?
Such as, as I mentioned above, anything basic added to water. Anything at all with the capacity to scavenge protons from its environment will produce OH- anions and it makes no difference to the quality of the OH- which base you use. They're marketing an electric device which doesn't do anything baking soda doesn't do, and then providing bullshit hand-waving explanations for why it's better than baking soda. There is only one real reason it's better than baking soda: People are willing to pay more for it because it sounds exotic and scientific- even though anyone with a modicum of chemistry background would laugh in their lying scamming faces.