Really, venues are a distraction, and so are identity politics not
explicitly tied to economic injustice.
Wayne County, Michigan: a net drop of 37,000 in voter turnout from 2012 to 2016. And 2012 was an incumbency year following a disillusioning Obama first term that solidified impressions about the synergistic relationship between government and financial/corporate capital after the collapse they triggered (whose "recovery" policy they got to shape). Wayne County is the seat of Detroit, which filed for chapter 9 bankruptcy after Obama squeaked by in 2012. Much of the "recovery" in Detroit involved the gutting of public institutions, and
rapid gentrification by white economic migrants taking advantage of collapse. In 2016, Trump won the state of Michigan by about 13,000 votes. That's a paltry 1/3 of the net drop in voters in Wayne County alone.
Raw trends are more stark. Despite economic malaise, the state saw between 40,000 and 100,000 net rise in voter registrations. Smaller counties adjacent to Wayne saw a net rise in votes, including Oakland and Macomb. Oakland contains one of Detroit's satellite cities, Troy, which felt the economic wallop like Detroit did, but Oakland is also one of the
wealthiest counties in the country, on the balance of all the less affected white "professional" suburbanites there, which make a much larger slice of the population there than in Wayne. Wayne's population has steadily shrunk since the collapse, Oakland's has steadily grown - an echo of gentrification. Oakland was a wash: Clinton still won Oakland, with about 6000 fewer votes than Obama; Trump lost the county, with about 5000 fewer votes than Romney. Johnson (libertarian) hoovered up 23,000 votes. Those weren't going to be for Clinton.
Neither were Wayne County's 18,000 Johnson votes. But Trump "lost" Wayne and got 15,000 more votes than Romney had (see if it makes sense to think of Johnson's 18,000 as additional votes he
failed to get). And Clinton "won" Wayne County but got
76,000 fewer votes than Obama. That "-37,000", then, tells us much less than that -76,000. And racist commie-bros doesn't explain what happened in the
brownest city in America (and where Clinton won the primary by a larger margin than any other county in the state).
Edit: spelling
*