How will Brexit affect UK and the rest of EU?
Moderators: kiore, Blip, The_Metatron
scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
Corneel wrote:scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
There is no such thing as EU citizenship.
What exists is citizenship of an EU member state. If and/or when the UK leaves the EU, UK citizens aren't citizens of an EU member state anymore. There is no change in citizenship, there is a change in what that citizenship entails.
scott1328 wrote:Corneel wrote:scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
There is no such thing as EU citizenship.
What exists is citizenship of an EU member state. If and/or when the UK leaves the EU, UK citizens aren't citizens of an EU member state anymore. There is no change in citizenship, there is a change in what that citizenship entails.
but why does it have to be that way?
Corneel wrote:Of course, I also expect such a deal being contingent on reciprocity, that means the same courtesy being extended to citizens of EU countries in the UK.
scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
Byron wrote:Ireland's passport authorities are also under siege!
As the Irish govt. have sensibly reminded people, there'll be no change in citizenship status for at least two years, likely longer. In that time, British citizens remain EU citizens, with full rights of movement, work and abode. If that status is ever seriously threatened, it'll bring down the British government, and halt Brexit negotiatons in their tracks.
GrahamH wrote:scott1328 wrote:Why is it that all Britons lose their EU citizenship when the UK leaves the EU. Couldn't every current EU citizen retain their citizenship, while naturalized and new born UK citizens going forward do not gain EU citizenship?
This would allow for a smoothing of the cut-over and ease some of the travel pains and ex-pat issues. And allow those Britons wanting to relocate to exercise the very right that lead to the divorce in the first place? I can even see the EU allowing Britons to retain citizenship rights if they elect to pay a tax to the EU for the privilege, or those not desirous of those rights a one-time opt-out.
Can you naturalise or take up dual citizenship?
Clearly you need to be a citizen of an EU country to be an EU citizen.
This might be helpful:
http://www.theguardian.com/politics/201 ... -in-europe
Veida wrote:Why do you think it will bring down the British government? Will a it change the minds of those 52% ?
Byron wrote:Unless they do something spectacularly stupid like triggering Article 50 before negotiations are signed, sealed and delivered, yup, ball's in their court (the EU's already taken legal advice and given up trying to force it).
Corneel wrote:Byron wrote:Unless they do something spectacularly stupid like triggering Article 50 before negotiations are signed, sealed and delivered, yup, ball's in their court (the EU's already taken legal advice and given up trying to force it).
How do you square that with today's announcement by Merkel, Hollande and Renzi (and Tusk and Juncker concurred) that there'll be no negotiations before article 50 is triggered?
Return to News, Politics & Current Affairs
Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 1 guest