HomerJay wrote:Nora_Leonard wrote:However, whereas I agree that this is a topic of considerable debate among Muslims, the fact is that there are places in Britain, e.g. where I live, where Muslims make up a substantial percentage of the population (~25%), and many of these Muslims are newly arrived refugees with very fixed ideas of what rules they need to follow. To ban the hijab in schools would cause enormous consternation and probably widespread demand for Muslim schools. This way these children get a secular rather than religious education.
However IMO there are other far more important battles to be fought than forbidding the wearing of a headscarf.
Cheers, Nora
I think it is highly and unnecessarily disingenuous to say many, as a percentage of asylum seekers or immigrants or the muslim population the number is very small.
Again, I specifically said "where I live". My borough has the second highest number of Somali refugees (8% of the school population) in the country, Cardiff being the first. We also have Muslim refugees from central Europe.
HomerJay wrote:The 'battle' you see is about forbidding headscarves, not about secularism and democracy, which is what it is really about.
Whereas I see making the small compromise of allowing Muslim girls to wear the hijab minor as compared to risking them being withdrawn from school altogether. Muslim hijab-wearing girls brought up in the state school system are going to appreciate secularism and democracy IMO.
HomerJay wrote:BTW There is an enormous demand for muslim schools already but I find it bizarre how you think we should cave in so easily, I would put it down to an enforced reverence for religion that you have been unable to shake off. Bear in mind of course, that where you favour the religious over the secular you are discriminating against the rest of us and have lost sight of some fairly basic democratic norms.
This is, of course, your opinion, and you are entitled to it. I do not feel that we are 'caving' in any way. I was asked the other day by a school governor whether schools were obliged to provide prayer rooms for Muslim parents, and I said Of course not. They are not even obliged to provide prayer rooms for Muslim staff or students, however IMO it is good practice to have a quiet area if Muslims want to do their midday prayers, especially during Ramadan.
As for me having an enforced reverence for religion that I have been unable to shake off... How well you know me...not!
I will not deny that there are aspects of human life that I respect that are embedded in religious tradition that I would not want to see done away with. Most of these have to do with cultivating an inner life, which, as a strong introvert, is very important to me.
Although I did, in my youth, go through a very strong phase of anger at the Church, what I don't seem to have any more is the antipathy towards anything religious which some people on this forum seem to have.